Pout Perfect Book

Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner vs. K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyeliner

7 comments

Beauty Articles, Featured | by — October 15, 2011

 

This is a short comparison review of two smudge-proof liquid eyeliners that I love.  However one of them lived a fleeting life in my “Holy Grail” hall of fame, and was out throned by an unsuspecting contendant.  Don’t get me wrong – both are still very good, but I love one of these just a whole lot more.

Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner

Pros

  • Adorable girly pink & black polka dot packaging
  • Fine felt tip
  • Long lasting & smudgeproof
  • Under $20 AUD

Cons

  • After about 2 months of use, the felt tip begins to fray & although there’s plenty of ink left, it becomes increasingly difficult to draw a sharp flick
  • The ink moves a little when wet, as seen in the swatch comparison further below

Even when both are brand new, K-Palette is much sharper

K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyeliner

Pros

  • Ultra sharp felt tip (K Palette also has an even thinner felt tip if you want pencil thin lines)
  • Long lasting & smudgeproof
  • Under $20 AUD
  • Even after 3 months of use, the felt tip is still sharp (see pictures below)
  • On direct application, the wet ink stays put better than Dolly Wink (see swatch comparison below)

Cons

  • Plain packaging, on the verge of boring

 

2 months old vs. Brand New K-Palette liners. Need I say more?

K-Palette ink stays put better than Dolly Wink

It’s not hard to see why K-Palette is a winner on all aspects (maybe except for packaging). If you already own a Dolly Wink liner, make it your last one & try K-Palette next time.   For those that still want to give Dolly Wink ago, I have pasted some links below where you can find these online.

Have you tried K-Palette liquid eyeliners?
Do you know of any liquid liner that does a better job than this?

 

Both products were purchased with my own money.

7 Responses to “Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner vs. K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyeliner”

  1. I’m a Dollywink fan but have not tried K-Palette….I don’t really face the fraying issue with my Dollywink liquid liner though….I don’t use it daily so could be why…

  2. Celeste @ Becoming Beautiful says:

    Awesome comparison. I’ve been wondering how they compare up to each other as well. I’ve tried Dollywink but not K-Palette!

  3. Dulce says:

    Now I’m in the middle of beauty shopping at sasa taking advantage of the free shipping offer, so I wanted to buy the dolly wink eyeliner. I’m currently using K-palette liquid eyeliner, so I looked for a review, and here I am. Very good post on the comparisons between these eyeliners. Now I know that K-Palette is better but I also like the cute packaging of dolly wink. I’m torn between quality or cuteness hahaha 😉

  4. Natsu says:

    I’ve been using K-palette all these years and it’s been an awesome eyeliner. Friends have been telling me about Dolly Wink and after some shopping I’ve finally found your review and decided that I would stick with K-palette.

    My previous pen was a limited edition metallic-pewter colored casing and I’ve been searching online for it to no avail. So I’m left with the plain black stick, which is a downer. Still, the best liner out there since forever. You don’t know how many types/brands I tried before I found this. I rmbr weeping tears of joy with it on and it didn’t even smudge!

  5. […] my daily eye makeup routine, I layer this pencil liner underneath my staple liquid eyeliner – K-Palette 1 Day Tattoo Real Lasting Eyeliner which worked together in keeping the overall effect intense […]

Leave a Reply